On February 28 in Nature Genetics online, geneticists from the International Genomics of Alzheimer’s Project published the largest genome-wide association meta-analysis to date. Brian Kunkle, University of Miami Miller School of Medicine, Benjamin Grenier-Boley, INSERM, Lille, France, and colleagues, including five research conglomerates, collaborated to analyze data from 35,274 people who had been diagnosed with late-onset Alzheimer’s disease. They identified five new loci with genome-wide significance. They fell near the IQCK, ACE, ADAM10, ADAMTS1, and WWOX genes. The last encodes a protein believed to interact with tau.
The paper follows the January 7 publication in Nature Genetics of a massive GWAS/GWAX study. In GWAX, researchers study AD by proxy, using not diagnosed AD cases, but people with a family history of the disease—the idea being that they carry a higher genetic risk for the disorder. Iris Jansen and Jeanne Savage, VU University, Amsterdam, and colleagues reported nine new risk loci for AD among a total of 71,880 diagnosed or proxy cases. This analysis also turned up ADAM10. The other eight hits lay near the ADAMTS4, HESX1, CLNK, CNTNAP2, APH1B, KAT8, ALPK2, and AC074212.3 genes.
These two papers follow the publication in May 2018 of another GWAX. Riccardo Marioni and colleagues at the University of Edinburgh analyzed IGAP data to identify ADAM10, ACE, and KAT8 as AD loci (Marioni et al., 2018). Alzforum covered these papers when they were uploaded to the BioRχiv preprint server (Apr 2018 news).
“These three papers mark steady progress in the identification of new loci for AD in Caucasian populations,” noted John Hardy, University College London. He was one of 474 co-authors on the Kunkle paper. “As more loci are identified, nearly all of them fit into categories that are already established—lipid metabolism, microglial activation, and APP processing.”
Since Kunkle and colleagues uploaded their paper to BioRχiv, they have analyzed roughly an additional 4,600 case/control samples in a replication analysis. “That led to the additional genome-wide locus at WWOX, which we did not have in the BioRχiv,” said Kunkle.
How might these loci contribute to AD risk? The functional variants are yet to be identified. Meanwhile, Kunkle and colleagues ranked genes near the loci for their likely involvement in AD pathogenesis based on eight criteria: deleterious coding, loss of function, or splicing variant in the gene; significance in gene-based testing; expression in a tissue relevant to AD, including astrocytes, neurons, microglia/macrophages, and oligodendrocytes; enrichment in a human microglial (HuMi) database (Olah et al., 2018); correlation with expression quantitative trait loci (eQTL) in any tissue, an AD-relevant tissue, or co-localization with an eQTL; being involved in a biological pathway enriched in AD; expression being correlated with BRAAK stage; and evidence of differential expression in more than one AD study (see figure below).
Top Hits. A biological ranking system prioritizes genes near known and newly discovered GWAS hits. [Courtesy of Kunkle et al., Nature Genetics 2019.]
By this ranking, ADAM10, which encodes α-secretase, was the top hit near that locus. The secretase is well known for non-amyloid processing of amyloid-β precursor protein (APP) and for shedding the ectodomain of TREM2, the microglial receptor that carries AD risk variants in its own right. While APP lies near the ADAMTS1 locus, the researchers believe ADAMTS1 itself the likely gene at that locus, though they do not rule out it regulating APP somehow. ADAMTS1 encodes ADAM metalloproteinase with thrombospondin type 1 motif, a potentially neuroprotective factor that is induced by interleukin-1β (Kuno et al., 1997). ICQX was also the top rank near its locus. This function of this gene is unclear, but it has been linked to obesity. Ranking high near the ACE locus were immune response genes, including PSMC5, MAP3K3, and CD79B. ACE itself might be a candidate since it has been previously linked to LOAD and Aβ levels (Baranello et al., 2015; Kauwe et al., 2014).
Near the WWOX locus the WW-domain containing oxidoreductase gene itself ranked highly, but so did MAF, which encodes a transcription factor expressed in microglia and macrophages. “Studies have shown that WWOX may control neuronal survival and block neurodegeneration via direct binding of tau or interactions with tau-phosphorylating enzymes,” noted Kunkle (Sze et al., 2004). WWOX dysfunction might also cause aggregation of tau and Aβ (Chang and Chang, 2015). “It is also possible that WWOX or a gene in this locus influences risk of Alzheimer’s through other mechanisms. For instance, this locus has been associated with obesity, HDL cholesterol, and triglyceride levels, all of which may influence Alzheimer’s risk,” wrote Kunkle.
Jansen and Savage took a similar approach, using three mapping strategies to link the genetic loci to potential functional genes. They identified 99 genes that lay within 10 kilobases of a locus, matched loci to 168 genes via eQTL analysis, and linked loci to 21 genes based on tertiary structure of chromatin. In other words, they tried to find distant DNA regions that might contort to juxtapose the AD loci when the DNA is wound (see image below).
Any two methods together identified 80 genes; all three methods identified 16. Notable hits were CLU and PTK2B on chromosome 8, which may interact or confer risk independently. ADMTS4 itself might be a risk factor since it has been implicated in AD previously. Ditto for ADAM10 and APH1B, which encodes a component of γ-secretase. The researchers noted that expression and methylation of KAT8, a lysine acetyltransferase, are regulated by numerous variants near that locus, making it a likely functional candidate. It is also regulated by KANSL1, a component of a histone acetylation complex that the authors say has been associated with AD in the absence of an ApoE4 allele.
Kunkle and colleagues also gauged how loci might relate to other co-morbidities. To do so, they correlated LOAD genetics with 792 other human diseases, traits, and behaviors. Family history of AD, fewer years of education, and indications of cardiovascular disease positively correlated with LOAD, while intelligence and more years of education correlated negatively. Some correlations were complex—many individual measures of cardiovascular disease and diabetes, such as family history of high blood pressure and fasting insulin, negatively correlated with AD, which the authors suggest is evidence that treating these disorders may be protective.
Where do GWAS studies go from here? Kunkle and colleagues noted loci that deserve further study because they almost reached genome-wide significance, including those near miR142/TSPOAP1-AS1, NDUFAF6, NME8, and MEF2C genes. Still, Hardy thinks the AD field is coming to the end of GWAS in Caucasians. “For related phenotypes, such as dementia with Lewy bodies and progressive supranuclear palsy, the current GWAS are small and more are needed. For AD, we clearly need GWAS in Asian and African populations,” he wrote.
Senior authors on the Kunkle paper were Agustin Ruiz, Universitat Internacional de Catalunya, Barcelona, Spain; Cornelia M. van Duijn, Medical Center, Rotterdam, the Netherlands; Peter A. Holmans and Julie Williams, Cardiff University, U.K.; Sudha Seshadri, Boston University; Phillippe Amouyel and Jean-Charles Lambert, University of Lille; Gerard D. Schellenberg, University of Pennsylvania Perelman School of Medicine, Philadelphia; and Margaret Pericak-Vance from the University of Miami.
Stephan Ripke, Charité–Universitätsmedizin, Berlin, Ole Andreassen, University of Oslo, and Danielle Posthuma at VU University were co-senior authors on the Jansen paper.—Tom Fagan
- Marioni RE, Harris SE, Zhang Q, McRae AF, Hagenaars SP, Hill WD, Davies G, Ritchie CW, Gale CR, Starr JM, Goate AM, Porteous DJ, Yang J, Evans KL, Deary IJ, Wray NR, Visscher PM. GWAS on family history of Alzheimer's disease. Transl Psychiatry. 2018 May 18;8(1):99. PubMed.
- Olah M, Patrick E, Villani AC, Xu J, White CC, Ryan KJ, Piehowski P, Kapasi A, Nejad P, Cimpean M, Connor S, Yung CJ, Frangieh M, McHenry A, Elyaman W, Petyuk V, Schneider JA, Bennett DA, De Jager PL, Bradshaw EM. A transcriptomic atlas of aged human microglia. Nat Commun. 2018 Feb 7;9(1):539. PubMed.
- Kuno K, Kanada N, Nakashima E, Fujiki F, Ichimura F, Matsushima K. Molecular cloning of a gene encoding a new type of metalloproteinase-disintegrin family protein with thrombospondin motifs as an inflammation associated gene. J Biol Chem. 1997 Jan 3;272(1):556-62. PubMed.
- Baranello RJ, Bharani KL, Padmaraju V, Chopra N, Lahiri DK, Greig NH, Pappolla MA, Sambamurti K. Amyloid-beta protein clearance and degradation (ABCD) pathways and their role in Alzheimer's disease. Curr Alzheimer Res. 2015;12(1):32-46. PubMed.
- Kauwe JS, Bailey MH, Ridge PG, Perry R, Wadsworth ME, Hoyt KL, Staley LA, Karch CM, Harari O, Cruchaga C, Ainscough BJ, Bales K, Pickering EH, Bertelsen S, Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative, Fagan AM, Holtzman DM, Morris JC, Goate AM. Genome-wide association study of CSF levels of 59 alzheimer's disease candidate proteins: significant associations with proteins involved in amyloid processing and inflammation. PLoS Genet. 2014 Oct;10(10):e1004758. Epub 2014 Oct 23 PubMed.
- Sze CI, Su M, Pugazhenthi S, Jambal P, Hsu LJ, Heath J, Schultz L, Chang NS. Down-regulation of WW domain-containing oxidoreductase induces Tau phosphorylation in vitro. A potential role in Alzheimer's disease. J Biol Chem. 2004 Jul 16;279(29):30498-506. PubMed.
- Chang JY, Chang NS. WWOX dysfunction induces sequential aggregation of TRAPPC6AΔ, TIAF1, tau and amyloid β, and causes apoptosis. Cell Death Discov. 2015;1:15003. Epub 2015 Aug 3 PubMed.
No Available Further Reading
- Kunkle BW, Grenier-Boley B, Sims R, Bis JC, Damotte V, Naj AC, Boland A, Vronskaya M, van der Lee SJ, Amlie-Wolf A, Bellenguez C, Frizatti A, Chouraki V, Martin ER, Sleegers K, Badarinarayan N, Jakobsdottir J, Hamilton-Nelson KL, Moreno-Grau S, Olaso R, Raybould R, Chen Y, Kuzma AB, Hiltunen M, Morgan T, Ahmad S, Vardarajan BN, Epelbaum J, Hoffmann P, Boada M, Beecham GW, Garnier JG, Harold D, Fitzpatrick AL, Valladares O, Moutet ML, Gerrish A, Smith AV, Qu L, Bacq D, Denning N, Jian X, Zhao Y, Del Zompo M, Fox NC, Choi SH, Mateo I, Hughes JT, Adams HH, Malamon J, Sanchez-Garcia F, Patel Y, Brody JA, Dombroski BA, Naranjo MC, Daniilidou M, Eiriksdottir G, Mukherjee S, Wallon D, Uphill J, Aspelund T, Cantwell LB, Garzia F, Galimberti D, Hofer E, Butkiewicz M, Fin B, Scarpini E, Sarnowski C, Bush WS, Meslage S, Kornhuber J, White CC, Song Y, Barber RC, Engelborghs S, Sordon S, Voijnovic D, Adams PM, Vandenberghe R, Mayhaus M, Cupples LA, Albert MS, De Deyn PP, Gu W, Himali JJ, Beekly D, Squassina A, Hartmann AM, Orellana A, Blacker D, Rodriguez-Rodriguez E, Lovestone S, Garcia ME, Doody RS, Munoz-Fernadez C, Sussams R, Lin H, Fairchild TJ, Benito YA, Holmes C, Karamujić-Čomić H, Frosch MP, Thonberg H, Maier W, Roschupkin G, Ghetti B, Giedraitis V, Kawalia A, Li S, Huebinger RM, Kilander L, Moebus S, Hernández I, Kamboh MI, Brundin R, Turton J, Yang Q, Katz MJ, Concari L, Lord J, Beiser AS, Keene CD, Helisalmi S, Kloszewska I, Kukull WA, Koivisto AM, Lynch A, Tarraga L, Larson EB, Haapasalo A, Lawlor B, Mosley TH, Lipton RB, Solfrizzi V, Gill M, Longstreth WT Jr, Montine TJ, Frisardi V, Diez-Fairen M, Rivadeneira F, Petersen RC, Deramecourt V, Alvarez I, Salani F, Ciaramella A, Boerwinkle E, Reiman EM, Fievet N, Rotter JI, Reisch JS, Hanon O, Cupidi C, Andre Uitterlinden AG, Royall DR, Dufouil C, Maletta RG, de Rojas I, Sano M, Brice A, Cecchetti R, George-Hyslop PS, Ritchie K, Tsolaki M, Tsuang DW, Dubois B, Craig D, Wu CK, Soininen H, Avramidou D, Albin RL, Fratiglioni L, Germanou A, Apostolova LG, Keller L, Koutroumani M, Arnold SE, Panza F, Gkatzima O, Asthana S, Hannequin D, Whitehead P, Atwood CS, Caffarra P, Hampel H, Quintela I, Carracedo Á, Lannfelt L, Rubinsztein DC, Barnes LL, Pasquier F, Frölich L, Barral S, McGuinness B, Beach TG, Johnston JA, Becker JT, Passmore P, Bigio EH, Schott JM, Bird TD, Warren JD, Boeve BF, Lupton MK, Bowen JD, Proitsi P, Boxer A, Powell JF, Burke JR, Kauwe JS, Burns JM, Mancuso M, Buxbaum JD, Bonuccelli U, Cairns NJ, McQuillin A, Cao C, Livingston G, Carlson CS, Bass NJ, Carlsson CM, Hardy J, Carney RM, Bras J, Carrasquillo MM, Guerreiro R, Allen M, Chui HC, Fisher E, Masullo C, Crocco EA, DeCarli C, Bisceglio G, Dick M, Ma L, Duara R, Graff-Radford NR, Evans DA, Hodges A, Faber KM, Scherer M, Fallon KB, Riemenschneider M, Fardo DW, Heun R, Farlow MR, Kölsch H, Ferris S, Leber M, Foroud TM, Heuser I, Galasko DR, Giegling I, Gearing M, Hüll M, Geschwind DH, Gilbert JR, Morris J, Green RC, Mayo K, Growdon JH, Feulner T, Hamilton RL, Harrell LE, Drichel D, Honig LS, Cushion TD, Huentelman MJ, Hollingworth P, Hulette CM, Hyman BT, Marshall R, Jarvik GP, Meggy A, Abner E, Menzies GE, Jin LW, Leonenko G, Real LM, Jun GR, Baldwin CT, Grozeva D, Karydas A, Russo G, Kaye JA, Kim R, Jessen F, Kowall NW, Vellas B, Kramer JH, Vardy E, LaFerla FM, Jöckel KH, Lah JJ, Dichgans M, Leverenz JB, Mann D, Levey AI, Pickering-Brown S, Lieberman AP, Klopp N, Lunetta KL, Wichmann HE, Lyketsos CG, Morgan K, Marson DC, Brown K, Martiniuk F, Medway C, Mash DC, Nöthen MM, Masliah E, Hooper NM, McCormick WC, Daniele A, McCurry SM, Bayer A, McDavid AN, Gallacher J, McKee AC, van den Bussche H, Mesulam M, Brayne C, Miller BL, Riedel-Heller S, Miller CA, Miller JW, Al-Chalabi A, Morris JC, Shaw CE, Myers AJ, Wiltfang J, O'Bryant S, Olichney JM, Alvarez V, Parisi JE, Singleton AB, Paulson HL, Collinge J, Perry WR, Mead S, Peskind E, Cribbs DH, Rossor M, Pierce A, Ryan NS, Poon WW, Nacmias B, Potter H, Sorbi S, Quinn JF, Sacchinelli E, Raj A, Spalletta G, Raskind M, Caltagirone C, Bossù P, Orfei MD, Reisberg B, Clarke R, Reitz C, Smith AD, Ringman JM, Warden D, Roberson ED, Wilcock G, Rogaeva E, Bruni AC, Rosen HJ, Gallo M, Rosenberg RN, Ben-Shlomo Y, Sager MA, Mecocci P, Saykin AJ, Pastor P, Cuccaro ML, Vance JM, Schneider JA, Schneider LS, Slifer S, Seeley WW, Smith AG, Sonnen JA, Spina S, Stern RA, Swerdlow RH, Tang M, Tanzi RE, Trojanowski JQ, Troncoso JC, Van Deerlin VM, Van Eldik LJ, Vinters HV, Vonsattel JP, Weintraub S, Welsh-Bohmer KA, Wilhelmsen KC, Williamson J, Wingo TS, Woltjer RL, Wright CB, Yu CE, Yu L, Saba Y, Alzheimer Disease Genetics Consortium (ADGC),, European Alzheimer’s Disease Initiative (EADI),, Cohorts for Heart and Aging Research in Genomic Epidemiology Consortium (CHARGE),, Genetic and Environmental Risk in AD/Defining Genetic, Polygenic and Environmental Risk for Alzheimer’s Disease Consortium (GERAD/PERADES),, Pilotto A, Bullido MJ, Peters O, Crane PK, Bennett D, Bosco P, Coto E, Boccardi V, De Jager PL, Lleo A, Warner N, Lopez OL, Ingelsson M, Deloukas P, Cruchaga C, Graff C, Gwilliam R, Fornage M, Goate AM, Sanchez-Juan P, Kehoe PG, Amin N, Ertekin-Taner N, Berr C, Debette S, Love S, Launer LJ, Younkin SG, Dartigues JF, Corcoran C, Ikram MA, Dickson DW, Nicolas G, Campion D, Tschanz J, Schmidt H, Hakonarson H, Clarimon J, Munger R, Schmidt R, Farrer LA, Van Broeckhoven C, C O'Donovan M, DeStefano AL, Jones L, Haines JL, Deleuze JF, Owen MJ, Gudnason V, Mayeux R, Escott-Price V, Psaty BM, Ramirez A, Wang LS, Ruiz A, van Duijn CM, Holmans PA, Seshadri S, Williams J, Amouyel P, Schellenberg GD, Lambert JC, Pericak-Vance MA. Genetic meta-analysis of diagnosed Alzheimer's disease identifies new risk loci and implicates Aβ, tau, immunity and lipid processing. Nat Genet. 2019 Mar;51(3):414-430. Epub 2019 Feb 28 PubMed.
- Jansen IE, Savage JE, Watanabe K, Bryois J, Williams DM, Steinberg S, Sealock J, Karlsson IK, Hägg S, Athanasiu L, Voyle N, Proitsi P, Witoelar A, Stringer S, Aarsland D, Almdahl IS, Andersen F, Bergh S, Bettella F, Bjornsson S, Brækhus A, Bråthen G, de Leeuw C, Desikan RS, Djurovic S, Dumitrescu L, Fladby T, Hohman TJ, Jonsson PV, Kiddle SJ, Rongve A, Saltvedt I, Sando SB, Selbæk G, Shoai M, Skene NG, Snaedal J, Stordal E, Ulstein ID, Wang Y, White LR, Hardy J, Hjerling-Leffler J, Sullivan PF, van der Flier WM, Dobson R, Davis LK, Stefansson H, Stefansson K, Pedersen NL, Ripke S, Andreassen OA, Posthuma D. Genome-wide meta-analysis identifies new loci and functional pathways influencing Alzheimer's disease risk. Nat Genet. 2019 Mar;51(3):404-413. Epub 2019 Jan 7 PubMed.