As if the genetic basis for amyotrophic lateral sclerosis was not complicated enough, attendees at the International Symposium on ALS/MND, 5-7 December 2012 in Chicago, Illinois, heard another wrinkle to the story. Michael van Es, of the University Medical Center in Utrecht, the Netherlands, proposed that in certain familial cases, not one but two major ALS risk genes contribute to disease. After screening families for known mutations, Van Es and his colleagues discovered far more double mutants than they would expect by chance alone. Mutations in one gene, a second, or both might explain why carriers in the same family often present with different phenotypes, or escape disease altogether, suggested van Es. The mechanism behind the dual-gene pathology remains unclear, and some scientists even doubt that mutant pairs work together.
Geneticists have typically explained the variable age at onset, speed of progression, and symptoms of people with the same ALS mutation by hypothesizing that other factors in their genomes, perhaps many variants, influence the disease. The Utrecht group’s “oligogenic” hypothesis is not that. It blames ALS phenotypes on two genetic co-stars, instead of one headliner and a supporting cast of bit players (Van Blitterswijk et al., 2012).
Van Es’ colleague Marka van Blitterswijk headed the study before moving to Rosa Rademakers' lab at the Mayo Clinic in Jacksonville, Florida. In an interview with Alzforum, she said the geneticists happened upon people carrying two ALS risk alleles when they set out to perform exome and whole genome sequencing. They checked their samples for known ALS mutations first, and discovered that five of their 97 families carried pairs of mutations. The angiogenin variant K17I showed up with FUS-R521C or TARDBP-N352S, a variant of the TDP-43 gene. C9ORF72 expansions paired with TARDBP-N352S, SOD1-D90A, or FUS-Q210H. In a further study published last month, Van Blitterswijk reported on a C9ORF72 expansion/VAPB-V234I duo (Van Blitterswijk et al., 2012).
In healthy control genomes, variants of known ALS genes only appeared in 0.5 percent of samples, and never more than one in a given person. The researchers calculated that the frequency of double mutations in families with ALS was well above the rate that should occur by chance.
However, the oligogenic interpretation is complicated by the fact that not all of the implicated variants are confirmed as pathogenic mutations. For example, FUS-Q210H and angiogenin-K17I also occurred individually in control subjects. Thus, they might not be causative mutations, but could still represent risk factors or disease modifiers, Van Blitterswijk suggested in an e-mail to Alzforum. Researchers debate the role of angiogenin as an ALS risk factor (see ARF related news story on Greenway et al., 2006; Corrado et al., 2007; Kirby et al., 2012), but several of the other mutations crop up in previously reported ALS cases. This includes FUS-R521C (Sproviero et al., 2011) and TARDBP-N352S, which was fairly common among Van Blitterswijk’s pedigrees (Kühnlein et al., 2008; Kamada et al., 2009). C9ORF72 expansions, recently discovered to be a long-sought risk factor, are prevalent in cases as well (see ARF related news story on Renton et al., 2011, and Dejesus-Hernandez et al., 2011). And SOD1-D90A is among the most frequent disease-causing SOD1 mutations globally (Rabe et al., 2010; Giannini et al., 2010; Eisen et al., 2008).
Other researchers have also reported cases with double mutations (Luigetti et al., 2011; Chiò et al., 2012; Lattante et al., 2012; Millecamps et al., 2010). Van Es said he is unsure how common pathogenic mutation pairs are overall. He hypothesized that the additive effects of two genetic risk alleles cause full-blown ALS in some families, while a single mutant allele may lead to different ALS or FTLD phenotypes, which may manifest as later onset of disease or slower progression. “It is more the sum of mutations that determines what the phenotype looks like, rather than individual mutations causing different phenotypes,” Van Es said. Importantly, that does not mean all inherited ALS cases result from a genetic double whammy, just that it is possible in some families, Van Blitterswijk noted.
Van Blitterswijk has taken the work a step further in her new position. Rademakers' group studies frontotemporal dementia (FTD), which shares several genes and features with ALS. As outlined in a poster at the Chicago conference, Van Blitterswijk examined DNA from people with known mutations in ALS and FTD genes, such as tau and progranulin, for the presence of the newly discovered C9ORF72 expansion. Again, she observed an unexpectedly high rate of double mutants—out of 218 families, three had a C9ORF72 expansion plus progranulin variants, and one had the C9ORF72 variant plus a tau mutation. The progranulin mutations included two frameshifts and an R493X substitution; the tau was P301L. All of these are linked to FTD beyond a doubt, Van Blitterswijk wrote (Huey et al., 2006; Spina et al., 2007; Pickering-Brown et al., 2008; Nasreddine et al., 1999). “This confirms the oligogenic pathogenesis and shows that it is not just specific for ALS; it can be detected in FTD patients as well,” Van Blitterswijk said.
Reaction from scientists has been mixed. Not all have embraced the hypothesis. Rademakers told Alzforum that she was initially skeptical, but now that she has seen how frequently mutations co-occur, she agrees that the pairs constitute a real phenomenon.
Guy Rouleau, of McGill University in Montréal, Canada, sees it differently. He argued that one of the two mutations is not a pathogenic mutation, but simply a benign variant. Just because the polymorphisms are present does not mean they contribute to disease, he told Alzforum, noting that every person’s genome is littered with variants that do not cause problems.
The presence of two mutations in so many ALS and FTD families has major implications for both researchers and the families, the presenters said. Scientists often eliminate carriers of known genes from new genetic analyses, but that would be a mistake if those carriers have more important mutations lurking in their genomes that researchers want to find. “I would advise we include [samples with known mutations] in any future screening to find evidence for double mutations,” Van Es said at the meeting.
Double mutations will complicate genetic counseling and risk prediction for families that harbor risk alleles. “I really do not know how we are going to work around this in clinical practice,” Van Es told Alzforum. “We do not know what to tell them anymore.” Already, Van Blitterswijk said she knows of one family that was seeing a genetic counselor, thinking they had only the angiogenin K17I variant to contend with (Van Es et al., 2009). Further testing showed that they also carried the TARDBP-N352S mutation.—Amber Dance.
- ALS—Study Strengthens VEGF Connection, Potential Biomarkers Proffered
- Corrupt Code: DNA Repeats Are Common Cause for ALS and FTD
- van Blitterswijk M, van Es MA, Hennekam EA, Dooijes D, van Rheenen W, Medic J, Bourque PR, Schelhaas HJ, van der Kooi AJ, de Visser M, de Bakker PI, Veldink JH, van den Berg LH. Evidence for an oligogenic basis of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. Hum Mol Genet. 2012 Sep 1;21(17):3776-84. Epub 2012 May 29 PubMed.
- van Blitterswijk M, van Es MA, Koppers M, van Rheenen W, Medic J, Schelhaas HJ, van der Kooi AJ, de Visser M, Veldink JH, van den Berg LH. VAPB and C9orf72 mutations in 1 familial amyotrophic lateral sclerosis patient. Neurobiol Aging. 2012 Dec;33(12):2950.e1-4. PubMed.
- Greenway MJ, Andersen PM, Russ C, Ennis S, Cashman S, Donaghy C, Patterson V, Swingler R, Kieran D, Prehn J, Morrison KE, Green A, Acharya KR, Brown RH, Hardiman O. ANG mutations segregate with familial and 'sporadic' amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. Nat Genet. 2006 Apr;38(4):411-3. PubMed.
- Corrado L, Battistini S, Penco S, Bergamaschi L, Testa L, Ricci C, Giannini F, Greco G, Patrosso MC, Pileggi S, Causarano R, Mazzini L, Momigliano-Richiardi P, D'Alfonso S. Variations in the coding and regulatory sequences of the angiogenin (ANG) gene are not associated to ALS (amyotrophic lateral sclerosis) in the Italian population. J Neurol Sci. 2007 Jul 15;258(1-2):123-7. PubMed.
- Kirby J, Highley JR, Cox L, Goodall EF, Hewitt C, Hartley JA, Hollinger HC, Fox M, Ince PG, McDermott CJ, Shaw PJ. Lack of unique neuropathology in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis associated with p.K54E angiogenin (ANG) mutation. Neuropathol Appl Neurobiol. 2012 Dec 10; PubMed.
- Sproviero W, La Bella V, Mazzei R, Valentino P, Rodolico C, Simone IL, Logroscino G, Ungaro C, Magariello A, Patitucci A, Tedeschi G, Spataro R, Condino F, Bono F, Citrigno L, Monsurrò MR, Muglia M, Gambardella A, Quattrone A, Conforti FL. FUS mutations in sporadic amyotrophic lateral sclerosis: Clinical and genetic analysis. Neurobiol Aging. 2011 Nov 3; PubMed.
- Kühnlein P, Sperfeld AD, Vanmassenhove B, Van Deerlin V, Lee VM, Trojanowski JQ, Kretzschmar HA, Ludolph AC, Neumann M. Two German kindreds with familial amyotrophic lateral sclerosis due to TARDBP mutations. Arch Neurol. 2008 Sep;65(9):1185-9. PubMed.
- Kamada M, Maruyama H, Tanaka E, Morino H, Wate R, Ito H, Kusaka H, Kawano Y, Miki T, Nodera H, Izumi Y, Kaji R, Kawakami H. Screening for TARDBP mutations in Japanese familial amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. J Neurol Sci. 2009 Sep 15;284(1-2):69-71. Epub 2009 May 2 PubMed.
- Renton AE, Majounie E, Waite A, Simón-Sánchez J, Rollinson S, Gibbs JR, Schymick JC, Laaksovirta H, van Swieten JC, Myllykangas L, Kalimo H, Paetau A, Abramzon Y, Remes AM, Kaganovich A, Scholz SW, Duckworth J, Ding J, Harmer DW, Hernandez DG, Johnson JO, Mok K, Ryten M, Trabzuni D, Guerreiro RJ, Orrell RW, Neal J, Murray A, Pearson J, Jansen IE, Sondervan D, Seelaar H, Blake D, Young K, Halliwell N, Callister JB, Toulson G, Richardson A, Gerhard A, Snowden J, Mann D, Neary D, Nalls MA, Peuralinna T, Jansson L, Isoviita VM, Kaivorinne AL, Hölttä-Vuori M, Ikonen E, Sulkava R, Benatar M, Wuu J, Chiò A, Restagno G, Borghero G, Sabatelli M, ITALSGEN Consortium, Heckerman D, Rogaeva E, Zinman L, Rothstein JD, Sendtner M, Drepper C, Eichler EE, Alkan C, Abdullaev Z, Pack SD, Dutra A, Pak E, Hardy J, Singleton A, Williams NM, Heutink P, Pickering-Brown S, Morris HR, Tienari PJ, Traynor BJ. A hexanucleotide repeat expansion in C9ORF72 is the cause of chromosome 9p21-linked ALS-FTD. Neuron. 2011 Oct 20;72(2):257-68. Epub 2011 Sep 21 PubMed.
- DeJesus-Hernandez M, Mackenzie IR, Boeve BF, Boxer AL, Baker M, Rutherford NJ, Nicholson AM, Finch NA, Flynn H, Adamson J, Kouri N, Wojtas A, Sengdy P, Hsiung GY, Karydas A, Seeley WW, Josephs KA, Coppola G, Geschwind DH, Wszolek ZK, Feldman H, Knopman DS, Petersen RC, Miller BL, Dickson DW, Boylan KB, Graff-Radford NR, Rademakers R. Expanded GGGGCC hexanucleotide repeat in noncoding region of C9ORF72 causes chromosome 9p-linked FTD and ALS. Neuron. 2011 Oct 20;72(2):245-56. Epub 2011 Sep 21 PubMed.
- Rabe M, Felbecker A, Waibel S, Steinbach P, Winter P, Ludolph AC. The epidemiology of CuZn-SOD mutations in Germany: a study of 217 families. J Neurol. 2010 Mar 23; PubMed.
- Giannini F, Battistini S, Mancuso M, Greco G, Ricci C, Volpi N, Del Corona A, Piazza S, Siciliano G. D90A-SOD1 mutation in ALS: The first report of heterozygous Italian patients and unusual findings. Amyotroph Lateral Scler. 2010;11(1-2):216-9. PubMed.
- Eisen A, Mezei MM, Stewart HG, Fabros M, Gibson G, Andersen PM. SOD1 gene mutations in ALS patients from British Columbia, Canada: clinical features, neurophysiology and ethical issues in management. Amyotroph Lateral Scler. 2008 Apr;9(2):108-19. PubMed.
- Luigetti M, Lattante S, Zollino M, Conte A, Marangi G, Del Grande A, Sabatelli M. SOD1 G93D sporadic amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (SALS) patient with rapid progression and concomitant novel ANG variant. Neurobiol Aging. 2011 Oct;32(10):1924.e15-8. PubMed.
- Chiò A, Restagno G, Brunetti M, Ossola I, Calvo A, Canosa A, Moglia C, Floris G, Tacconi P, Marrosu F, Marrosu MG, Murru MR, Majounie E, Renton AE, Abramzon Y, Pugliatti M, Sotgiu MA, Traynor BJ, Borghero G, . ALS/FTD phenotype in two Sardinian families carrying both C9ORF72 and TARDBP mutations. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 2012 Jul;83(7):730-3. PubMed.
- Lattante S, Conte A, Zollino M, Luigetti M, Del Grande A, Marangi G, Romano A, Marcaccio A, Meleo E, Bisogni G, Rossini PM, Sabatelli M. Contribution of major amyotrophic lateral sclerosis genes to the etiology of sporadic disease. Neurology. 2012 Jul 3;79(1):66-72. PubMed.
- Millecamps S, Salachas F, Cazeneuve C, Gordon P, Bricka B, Camuzat A, Guillot-Noël L, Russaouen O, Bruneteau G, Pradat PF, Le Forestier N, Vandenberghe N, Danel-Brunaud V, Guy N, Thauvin-Robinet C, Lacomblez L, Couratier P, Hannequin D, Seilhean D, Le Ber I, Corcia P, Camu W, Brice A, Rouleau G, LeGuern E, Meininger V. SOD1, ANG, VAPB, TARDBP, and FUS mutations in familial amyotrophic lateral sclerosis: genotype-phenotype correlations. J Med Genet. 2010 Aug;47(8):554-60. Epub 2010 Jun 24 PubMed.
- Huey ED, Grafman J, Wassermann EM, Pietrini P, Tierney MC, Ghetti B, Spina S, Baker M, Hutton M, Elder JW, Berger SL, Heflin KA, Hardy J, Momeni P. Characteristics of frontotemporal dementia patients with a Progranulin mutation. Ann Neurol. 2006 Sep;60(3):374-80. PubMed.
- Spina S, Murrell JR, Huey ED, Wassermann EM, Pietrini P, Baraibar MA, Barbeito AG, Troncoso JC, Vidal R, Ghetti B, Grafman J. Clinicopathologic features of frontotemporal dementia with progranulin sequence variation. Neurology. 2007 Mar 13;68(11):820-7. PubMed.
- Pickering-Brown SM, Rollinson S, Du Plessis D, Morrison KE, Varma A, Richardson AM, Neary D, Snowden JS, Mann DM. Frequency and clinical characteristics of progranulin mutation carriers in the Manchester frontotemporal lobar degeneration cohort: comparison with patients with MAPT and no known mutations. Brain. 2008 Mar;131(Pt 3):721-31. PubMed.
- Nasreddine ZS, Loginov M, Clark LN, Lamarche J, Miller BL, Lamontagne A, Zhukareva V, Lee VM, Wilhelmsen KC, Geschwind DH. From genotype to phenotype: a clinical pathological, and biochemical investigation of frontotemporal dementia and parkinsonism (FTDP-17) caused by the P301L tau mutation. Ann Neurol. 1999 Jun;45(6):704-15. PubMed.
- van Es MA, Diekstra FP, Veldink JH, Baas F, Bourque PR, Schelhaas HJ, Strengman E, Hennekam EA, Lindhout D, Ophoff RA, van den Berg LH. A case of ALS-FTD in a large FALS pedigree with a K17I ANG mutation. Neurology. 2009 Jan 20;72(3):287-8. PubMed.
- van Blitterswijk M, Dejesus-Hernandez M, Rademakers R. How do C9ORF72 repeat expansions cause amyotrophic lateral sclerosis and frontotemporal dementia: can we learn from other noncoding repeat expansion disorders?. Curr Opin Neurol. 2012 Dec;25(6):689-700. PubMed.
- Belzil VV, Daoud H, Camu W, Strong MJ, Dion PA, Rouleau GA. Genetic analysis of SIGMAR1 as a cause of familial ALS with dementia. Eur J Hum Genet. 2012 Jun 27; PubMed.
- Belzil VV, Langlais JS, Daoud H, Dion PA, Brais B, Rouleau GA. Novel FUS deletion in a patient with juvenile amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. Arch Neurol. 2012 May;69(5):653-6. PubMed.
- Schymick JC, Talbot K, Traynor BJ. Genetics of sporadic amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. Hum Mol Genet. 2007 Oct 15;16 Spec No. 2:R233-42. PubMed.
- Praline J, Vourc'h P, Guennoc AM, Veyrat-Durebex C, Corcia P. Co-occurrence of progressive anarthria with an S393L TARDBP mutation and ALS within a family. Amyotroph Lateral Scler. 2012 Jan;13(1):155-7. PubMed.
- Felbecker A, Camu W, Valdmanis PN, Sperfeld AD, Waibel S, Steinbach P, Rouleau GA, Ludolph AC, Andersen PM. Four familial ALS pedigrees discordant for two SOD1 mutations: are all SOD1 mutations pathogenic?. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 2010 May;81(5):572-7. PubMed.
- Gwinn K, Corriveau RA, Mitsumoto H, Bednarz K, Brown RH, Cudkowicz M, Gordon PH, Hardy J, Kasarskis EJ, Kaufmann P, Miller R, Sorenson E, Tandan R, Traynor BJ, Nash J, Sherman A, Mailman MD, Ostell J, Bruijn L, Cwik V, Rich SS, Singleton A, Refolo L, Andrews J, Zhang R, Conwit R, Keller MA, . Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis: an emerging era of collaborative gene discovery. PLoS One. 2007;2(12):e1254. PubMed.
- Chicago—ALS Database Opens for Business
- C9ORF72 Steals the Show at Frontotemporal Dementia Meeting
- DC: New ALS Genetics Hog the Limelight at Satellite Conference
- New ALS Genes Implicate Protein Degradation, Endoplasmic Reticulum
- A Fork in the Road: Angiogenin Predisposes to ALS and Parkinson’s
- Optineurin Mutations Cause ALS, If Not Glaucoma
- ALS—Study Strengthens VEGF Connection, Potential Biomarkers Proffered
- Adding ALS to the Manifestations of VCP Mutations
- Corrupt Code: DNA Repeats Are Common Cause for ALS and FTD
- Chicago—ALS Clinical Trials: New Hope After Phase 3 Setbacks
- Chicago—ALS Protein SOD1 Painted as Disease Template