Choi SH, Kim YH, Hebisch M, Sliwinski C, Lee S, D'Avanzo C, Chen H, Hooli B, Asselin C, Muffat J, Klee JB, Zhang C, Wainger BJ, Peitz M, Kovacs DM, Woolf CJ, Wagner SL, Tanzi RE, Kim DY. A three-dimensional human neural cell culture model of Alzheimer's disease. Nature. 2014 Nov 13;515(7526):274-8. Epub 2014 Oct 12 PubMed.

Recommends

Please login to recommend the paper.

Comments

  1. It is clear from genetics, biochemistry, and both animal studies and human studies that Aβ and tau are both important in causing Alzheimer’s disease.

    There is also a lot of suggestive data that the accumulation of Aβ in the brain somehow drives the accumulation and spread of tau aggregation and pathology in the brain, which is important in neurodegeneration. What is lacking in the field is a model in cell culture that recapitulates these key features of disease. In this paper by Choi et al., using human neural progenitor cells, the researchers show that by growing them in a three-dimensional matrix, there is not just increased levels of Aβ42 being produced, but there is clear-cut amyloid-plaque formation. This is the first time that I am aware of this being shown in cultured cells. Equally important, a form of tau that is more prone to aggregate, called 4-repeat tau, is produced by these human neural cells and in the presence of amyloid plaques, forms hyperphosphorylated, detergent-insoluble aggregates. This detergent-insoluble form of tau is what accumulates in Alzheimer’s disease and related disorders and is a signature of these diseases. This new model and findings are important for the following reasons:

    1.       It is the first time that Aβ plaques and neurofibrillary tangles containing tau form spontaneously in cultured cells;

    2.       The data strongly suggest that Aβ aggregation can directly lead to tau aggregation when using human cells;

    3.       This new system provides a nice model to determine how Aβ drives tau pathology;

    4.       This is now a model system to potentially rapidly test new treatments targeting Aβ, tau, or even other targets as new treatments.

    View all comments by David Holtzman

  2. The significance of this paper could be enormous if it facilitates discovery of mechanisms that link Aβ production/accumulation to tau pathology. In this model, the authors have shown Aβ accumulation, and tau becomes insoluble and hyperphosphorylated. This confirms and extends Shi et al., 2012, which reported similar findings in a different in vitro system.

    To further explore whether this system recapitulates AD in a dish, the identity of the neurofibrillary tangles could be probed at greater depth methodologically. The EM image provided is a start, but immuno-EM requires careful use of negative controls and blinded analyses to be sure. My experience in searching for fibrils under EM has been that it is not too hard to find fibril-like structures in the cell. It would be helpful to rule out that background staining by antibodies has labeled some other fibril-like cell structure. Therefore a next step in replicating this potentially very important finding would be to use unbiased metrics to analyze EM images. Another, simpler, step to ascertain that this system indeed accumulates intracellular amyloids is to perform amyloid stains on the cell culture.

    This study is a great start, and now requires replication in other labs.

    References:

    Shi Y, Kirwan P, Smith J, Maclean G, Orkin SH, Livesey FJ. A human stem cell model of early Alzheimer's disease pathology in Down syndrome. Sci Transl Med. 2012 Mar 7;4(124):124ra29. PubMed.

    View all comments by Marc Diamond

  3. This paper is an undoubted step forward in the extent of both amyloid and tau pathology. It is not correct, however, to say that this is entirely novel. Shi et al., 2012, showed both Aβ deposition and tau pathology in iPSC-derived neuron cultures derived from Down syndrome (i.e. in the context of physiological levels of expression).

    References:

    Shi Y, Kirwan P, Smith J, Maclean G, Orkin SH, Livesey FJ. A human stem cell model of early Alzheimer's disease pathology in Down syndrome. Sci Transl Med. 2012 Mar 7;4(124):124ra29. PubMed.

    View all comments by John Hardy

  4. This paper reports a long-overdue in vitro approach to a long-standing problem.

    Nevertheless, it is important to keep in mind that neurons in culture are in a permanently stressed situation that does not reflect normal neurons in the brain but could be construed to reflect stress as in AD. Moreover, the lentiviral transfection used to drive transgene expression to high levels stresses the cultured neurons even further. As important, an indisputable limitation of most transgenic models applies here, too, in that the cultured neurons express the APP Swedish and London double mutant plus the Δ9 presenilin mutant, and massively produce mutant APP and amyloid peptides.

    Even so, the outcome of combined amyloid and tau pathology appears most interesting for the amyloid cascade hypothesis. It replicates in vitro the important argument that even the most early onset, obligatory amyloid-driven familial forms of AD suffer tauopathy besides amyloid. The presence of both, of course, was Alois Alzheimer’s original definition of the disease based on Auguste Deter’s familial case, and it still holds. That said, this study still only speaks to FAD and does not model the causes of late-onset sporadic AD.

    The tauopathy outcome in this study conforms to our findings in APP-V717I (London) mouse brain that amyloid activates GSK3 and increases the phosphorylation of endogenous mouse protein tau from the age of three to six months, prior to amyloid deposition (Terwel et al., 2008). One cannot fully assess the extent and authenticity of tauopathy in this culture system from the data presented. We all know that is technically complex, even more in neuronal cultures than in brain. It will require western blotting and immunohistochemistry for other robust phospho-epitopes in addition to AT8 and PHF1, besides more extensive EM-ultrastructural analysis.

    An important point raised by this paper is the renewed implication of GSK3—either α or β or both—in AD. The study reinforces the argument, generally accepted in AD research, that GSK3 is the primary, though by no means the only, kinase that phosphorylates tau in vivo. GSK3 profoundly aggravates tauopathy and affects many neuronal functions and networks (Spittaels et al., 2000; Terwel et al., 2005, 2008; Crespo-Biel et al., 2014; Maurin et al., 2014).

    However, despite very intensive efforts from small and big pharma, GSK3 inhibitors have not yet made it into the clinic, and in my opinion they never will. The major reason is that GSK3 is expressed in most body tissues and involved in a great variety of signaling pathways, most of which are basic and essential for physiological functions. In brain, GSK3 is important for pre- and post-synaptic mechanisms underlying learning and memory, involving LTP and LTD, that we and many other groups are still trying to dissect (e.g., Ochs et al., 2014). Much as I welcome this renewed enthusiasm in our continued fight against this dreadful disease, GSK3 does not appear as a feasible drug target.

    As always, I am eagerly looking forward to follow-up studies to this new and interesting model.

    References:

    Terwel D, Muyllaert D, Dewachter I, Borghgraef P, Croes S, Devijver H, Van Leuven F. Amyloid activates GSK-3beta to aggravate neuronal tauopathy in bigenic mice. Am J Pathol. 2008 Mar;172(3):786-98. PubMed.

    Spittaels K, Van den Haute C, Van Dorpe J, Geerts H, Mercken M, Bruynseels K, Lasrado R, Vandezande K, Laenen I, Boon T, Van Lint J, Vandenheede J, Moechars D, Loos R, Van Leuven F. Glycogen synthase kinase-3beta phosphorylates protein tau and rescues the axonopathy in the central nervous system of human four-repeat tau transgenic mice. J Biol Chem. 2000 Dec 29;275(52):41340-9. PubMed.

    Terwel D, Lasrado R, Snauwaert J, Vandeweert E, Van Haesendonck C, Borghgraef P, Van Leuven F. Changed conformation of mutant Tau-P301L underlies the moribund tauopathy, absent in progressive, nonlethal axonopathy of Tau-4R/2N transgenic mice. J Biol Chem. 2005 Feb 4;280(5):3963-73. PubMed.

    Crespo-Biel N, Theunis C, Borghgraef P, Lechat B, Devijver H, Maurin H, Van Leuven F. Phosphorylation of protein Tau by GSK3β prolongs survival of bigenic Tau.P301L×GSK3β mice by delaying brainstem tauopathy. Neurobiol Dis. 2014 Jul;67:119-32. Epub 2014 Apr 2 PubMed.

    Maurin H, Chong SA, Kraev I, Davies H, Kremer A, Seymour CM, Lechat B, Jaworski T, Borghgraef P, Devijver H, Callewaert G, Stewart MG, Van Leuven F. Early structural and functional defects in synapses and myelinated axons in stratum lacunosum moleculare in two preclinical models for tauopathy. PLoS One. 2014;9(2):e87605. Epub 2014 Feb 3 PubMed.

    Ochs SM, Dorostkar MM, Aramuni G, Schön C, Filser S, Pöschl J, Kremer A, Van Leuven F, Ovsepian SV, Herms J. Loss of neuronal GSK3β reduces dendritic spine stability and attenuates excitatory synaptic transmission via β-catenin. Mol Psychiatry. 2014 Jun 10; PubMed.

    View all comments by Fred Van Leuven

  5. The impediment to making progress in AD research and finding a cure is not the lack of success of the traditional reductionist approach, where a complex phenomenon is broken down into individual components and studied to better understand the phenomenon. We fail in the “synthetic” approach, where individual components are put together to gain a more complete understanding of disease pathogenesis at the patient level.

    This study—the disease in a dish—is a brilliant piece of in vitro experimentation. The excitement it has generated will be fully manifested if it resonates with clinical findings. Unfortunately, here we are on shakier ground:

    1. In hundreds of brain autopsies, Braak and colleagues observed spatial and temporal dissociation between amyloid pathology and tau pathology, with the latter appearing decades prior to and in a different location in the brain than the former. The Lille group also demonstrated that tau pathology progresses from the limbic system to the neocortex, while amyloid pathology moves in the opposite direction. Thus, the in vitro insistence that amyloid pathology causes tau pathology is discordant with the fundamental in vivo clinical observations in late-onset AD.

    2. Brain imaging studies have shown that areas of amyloid deposits do not necessarily coincide with those of hypometabolism, which in turn do not coincide with those of brain atrophy. The simplest interpretation of the multimodal imaging data is that amyloid deposits are not toxic to nearby neurons in vivo (indeed, neurons in the Choi et al. study still looked healthy after six to eight weeks around amyloid deposits). If so, the potential of this new system for understanding the “pathogenic mechanisms of AD” might be overestimated.

    3. We cannot ignore that the SNAP phenomenon (individuals neurologically diagnosed as preclinical AD but lacking amyloid deposits by brain imaging) is observed in 20-25 percent of the population. While it is true that nosologically these patients may not be classified as AD as defined by Alois Alzheimer, it is clear that we can have symptoms of early AD in the absence of amyloid deposits.

    4. The simplicity of the three-dimensional cell culture system, which will allow screening of thousands of drug compounds quickly and inexpensively, may prove to be limiting because of the lack of a blood-brain barrier. Many drugs that showed promise in vitro and/or in mouse models are thought to have failed in clinical trials because of the impenetrable blood-brain barrier.

    This is not to rain on the amyloid parade. I am awed by the experimental manipulations described here. However, it is important to put these findings in context and provide a balanced view. As a field, we are better off if we underpromise and overdeliver.

    References:

    Braak H, Thal DR, Ghebremedhin E, Del Tredici K. Stages of the pathologic process in Alzheimer disease: age categories from 1 to 100 years. J Neuropathol Exp Neurol. 2011 Nov;70(11):960-9. PubMed.

    View all comments by Sanjay Pimplikar

  6. This study is a lovely confirmation of the cascade from amyloid to tau pathology in a human cellular system, and the first cell culture system that I have heard of to develop both plaques and tangles. While this new system is not a perfect recapitulation of sporadic Alzheimer's (as it relies on overexpression of proteins), having human cells develop the pathological hallmarks of Alzheimer's disease in a dish in a relatively short time frame is a leap forward for the field. This will allow rapid tests of new treatments in cells that have the same machinery as human patients, hopefully making these tests an accurate predictor of whether the treatments will work in people.

    View all comments by Tara Spires-Jones

Make a Comment

To make a comment you must login or register.